SYRACUSE, N.Y. (WSYR-TV) — Have you ever recovered out of your vacation binge? It will get simpler to overlook the times of overindulgence as they get farther and farther within the rear-view mirror. Possibly your candy tooth has come again to life or you’re on the lookout for a brand new Valentine’s Day dessert — both manner, you’re on the lookout for a deal with.
If one thing candy is what you search, these Syracuse websites can satiate your abdomen. NewsChannel 9 has compiled a listing containing a few of the finest locally-owned dessert retailers (at present open within the February chilly) in Syracuse, based on Google. If two eating places have the identical rank, the one with extra critiques will probably be ranked greater.
#20 Pie’s The Restrict – Salt Metropolis Market
Common Ranking: 4.4 stars. Opinions: 17
In 2019, Fiona Barbour Day based Pie’s The Limit. The next 12 months, she was requested to hitch the new Salt City Market. Fiona gives a mixture of candy and savory pies, every extra scrumptious than the final. These embrace a private pan Shaker Lemon Pie made with Meyer Lemons and a vegan Blueberry and Orange Galette. Pie’s The Restrict’s menu is at all times altering to remain contemporary with the seasons.
#19 The Cookie Connection – Mattydale
Common Ranking: 4.5 stars. Opinions: 27
The Cookie Connection is Syracuse’s first gluten-free bakeshop licensed by the Nationwide Celiac Affiliation. Their objective, based on their web site, is “to permit everybody, no matter any well being points, to have the ability to acquire good tasting, wholesome, preservative-free baked items.” Whereas the shop has restricted hours, their number of treats just isn’t! The Cookie Connection gives delicious classics like half-moon cookies and 15 different flavors of cake.
#18 CupCakers – Liverpool
Common Ranking: 4.6 stars. Opinions: 91
CupCakers is a connoisseur bakery on Outdated Liverpool Street that makes a speciality of cupcakes. They’ve over 50 flavors of cupcakes to order, together with seasonal and alcohol-infused flavors like Bailey’s and Raspberry Lime Margarita. Along with cupcakes, they provide cream pies, cookie sandwiches, cheesecake pies, and brownie bars… Yum. They’ll additionally sometimes provide occasions with distinctive snacks, like hot soft pretzels with homemade sauces.
#17 The Toast – Cazenovia
Common Ranking: 4.6 stars. Opinions: 368
The Toast in Cazenovia describes itself as an artisanal bakery. It looks like an correct assertion as a few of their pastries look like works of art! They provide macaroons in many alternative flavors like pineapple upside-down, lemon blueberry, and raspberry cream; Berry and Asian Pear fruit tarts, s’extra cookies, and a number of other different tasty treats which you’ll be able to munch on. You’ll be able to see extra of their delicacies on their Facebook or Instagram.
#16 Cathy’s Cookie Kitchen – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 54
Cathy’s Cookie Kitchen is a staple of Armory Sq., specializing in — imagine it or not — cookies! Cathy’s Cookie Kitchen’s s’mores chocolate chip, Milky Manner chocolate chip, and Heath Bar crunch chocolate chip had been all voted “Greatest Desserts” throughout Syracuse’s Winterfest 2018, 2019, and 2020 and featured on NewsChannel 9’s Bridge Street. Cathy’s Cookie Kitchen even gives supply straight to Syracuse College scholar dorms and a “cookie of the month” membership!
#15 Exhale Café & Bake Store – Camillus
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 58
Exhale Café and Bake Shop is owned by Maria Eliana, a classically educated baker. Exhale Café and Bake Store gives basic treats and distinctive creations alike, equivalent to Blondies, M&M Bars, and pink velvet lattes. Exhale Café and Bake Store additionally creates customized order truffles and can design something — including a ‘fancy’ Jesus in a suit! Her retailer has been described as “effin’ cozy” by Amelia C. on Google.
#14 Serres Donut Store – East Syracuse
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 128
Serres Donut Shop is the definition of a mom-and-pop store and has served scrumptious donuts in East Syracuse for over 40 years. Their retailer and choices is likely to be easy and basic, however they at all times have a plehora of treats which are assured to fulfill that craving. Their costs have additionally at all times been cheap, and final time we had been there, you can get a dozen donuts for $7.99 — $2 lower than Dunkin’ and made loads nearer to dwelling.
#13 JessiCakes – Baldwinsville
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 150
JessiCakes is the proper spot for tasting nice desserts and supporting an important trigger. Proprietor Jessica Doran has a daughter with autism and makes use of the bakeshop as a spot for different younger individuals with autism to develop abilities and have enjoyable. Collectively they create delicious cookies, custom cakes, and an enormous number of chocolate covered strawberries!
#12 The Candy Praxis – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 267
The Sweet Praxis, based on their Facebook page, is a “bake lab + kitchen providing handmade pastries and baked items”. When you visited them at 2021’s Nice New York State Truthful, you might have gotten an opportunity to style what they imply by taking dwelling a cone of chocolate chip cookies or an edible cookie dough cup! Regardless, you’ll be able to nonetheless get your candy repair at The Candy Praxis by munching on a s’mores cereal bar, a Salt Metropolis brownie, or a combined berry hand pie. In the event that they’re a bake lab, contemplate me a scientist.
#11 Glazed & Confused – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.7 stars. Opinions: 641
Glazed & Confused is one other space staple, providing award-winning donuts. Generally their treats have cool designs, like ones with a Bills theme or ones that featured County Executive Ryan McMahon’s face. Whereas these designs may not be round anymore, you’ll be able to nonetheless expertise the scrumptious style of their donuts: flavors like banana break up and peanut butter and chocolate don’t disappoint.
#10 Huge MaMa’s Cheesecakes – Syracuse
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 18
Big MaMa’s Cheesecakes started as a cheesecake wholesaler, however the retailer’s reputation at occasions just like the Style of Syracuse and the Nice New York State Truthful spurred proprietor Carrie Fanizzi to create a storefront by Provider Circle, a call that we must always profusely thank her for. The store also recently had the roof blown off, and the cheesecake flavors supplied, like creamsicle, apple caramel, and cookie monster, may do the identical to your tastebuds.
#9 Peace, Love, and Cupcakes – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 104
Returning to conventional desserts, Peace, Love, and Cupcakes is one other native highlight. Proprietor Rebecca Riley can do all of it however is most obsessed with cupcakes. Her creations look nice and style simply as good. Peace, Love, and Cupcakes additionally reveals unbelievable assist to the Syracuse neighborhood, whether or not it’s donating 100% of cookie proceeds to local non-profits. donating 10% of daily sales in the memory of customers, or simply sharing content from other local and supportive business owners.
#8 Bella Bakery – Lakeland
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 133
Bella Bakery in Lakeland is one other space hidden gem with a diehard fanbase. They focus on Italian and Jap European cookies and have been serving the Syracuse space for years. They’re so devoted to their craft that John Bella, the proprietor, says his grandfather was born within the bakery, based on legend (and their firm web site). The dedication reveals of their scrumptious treats: Italian cookies, pies, and conventional truffles.
#7 Hercules Sweet – East Syracuse
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 576
Hercules Candy has had over 100 years to good the artwork of constructing sweet in East Syracuse and is a can’t-miss spot. They make all of their treats by hand with none machines and roast their very own nuts — and it reveals. They’ve all types of sweets, from ribbon candy to chocolate, and every gives a singular style. When you want some affirmation, you’ll be able to take a look at their social media: they’ve this checklist’s most Facebook likes, with 86,771 and over 100,000 followers, over 145 million total views on YouTube, and have been featured on BuzzFeed. They even have their own subreddit!
#6 Eva’s European Sweets – Solvay
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 797
Eva’s European Sweets has been the CNY dwelling for genuine Polish sweets since 1997. Eva’s has been named Yelp’s top spot to eat in Syracuse and was featured on Guy Fieri’s Syracuse tour in 2013. Whereas Man Fieri missed out on her sweets, we don’t suppose it’s best to! Eva’s European Sweets gives an enormous number of desserts to select from, together with cherry crumb pie, chocolate ganache cake, and a espresso buttercream cake.
#5 Candy on Chocolate – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.9 stars. Opinions: 65
Sweet on Chocolate is one other can’t-miss spot for chocolate sweet in Syracuse. With a rotating menu, you’ll at all times have an opportunity to attempt a brand new chocolate mix, whether or not it’s within the type of truffles, creams, turtles, clusters, or barks. When you can title it, Candy on Chocolate most likely has it! Even though the ownership changed hands back in 2018, the outstanding high quality has stayed the identical.
#4 Mrs. Kelder’s Muffins – Manlius
Common Ranking: 4.9 stars. Opinions: 44
Whereas Mrs. Kelder’s Cakes is likely one of the many dessert shops within the Syracuse space, they’re top-of-the-line. Mrs. Kelder has perfected the artwork of frosting, mixing delectable colours and style along with nice presentation. Mrs. Kelder’s Muffins additionally has some very artistic recipes for her fabulous and reasonably priced cupcakes, such because the Irish Automotive Bomb: a chocolate Guinness cupcake, crammed with Irish cream buttercream (Irish cream and Irish whiskey), and topped with chocolate buttercream. The shop additionally gives native supply inside 5 miles!
#3 🥉 Candy Dream Sweet Shoppe – Baldwinsville
Common Ranking: 5.0 stars. Opinions: 8
Sweet Dream Candy Shoppe is within the coronary heart of the Village of Baldwinsville and can most likely win over your coronary heart for those who step inside. The shop boasts a formidable number of sweet — it’s virtually intimidating! Fortunately, the proprietor is a sweet skilled and can make it easier to resolve the proper deal with to your go to, whether or not you’re within the temper for a classic candy or something artisanal.
#2 🥈 Westcott Cookie Firm – Downtown
Common Ranking: 5.0 stars. Opinions: 23
Westcott Cookie Company is a “vibey dessert café serving cookies, signature dessert drinks, gourmet hot chocolate, and other treats” in Downtown Syracuse. In keeping with their web site, their story is straightforward: “Man makes cookies. Pals eat his cookies. Pals say ‘it’s best to promote these cookies.’ Man begins promoting cookies.” However their critiques and feedback and Instagram appear to suppose their flavors are something however easy — particularly their (already well-known) salted chocolate chip cookie.
Honorable Mentions 🏅
Fashionable Malt – Downtown
Common Ranking: 4.2 stars. Opinions: 1,180
Modern Malt joined the scrumptious horde of eating places in Downtown Syracuse in 2014. Whereas not solely a dessert store, a few of their breakfast gadgets are candy and attractive sufficient to avoid wasting for dessert — for those who can maintain off that lengthy. These embrace the “Barney Rubble,” a fruity-pebble-crusted French toast, and the s’mores waffle, which is — you guessed it — a waffle made with chocolate chips, toasted marshmallows, and graham cracker. You can also’t overlook to attempt certainly one of their scrumptious milkshakes, equivalent to the Wildberry Pop-Tart.
Ma & Pa’s Kettle Corn and Popcorn Manufacturing facility – Liverpool
Common Ranking: 4.8 stars. Opinions: 103
Whereas kettle corn is likely to be thought of only a snack, the massive number of popcorn and scrumptious flavors that Ma & Pa’s Kettle Corn and Popcorn Factory provide positively pushes them into dessert class. Some kettle corn flavors embrace lemon pound cake and snickerdoodle; Ma & Pa’s additionally sells super-sweet candied corns, like birthday cake, cinna-bun, and sour patch. You may also get caramel-chocolate drizzled popcorn and even caramel-coated cheese balls that you simply may acknowledge from the Great New York State Fair.
And the winner is… 🏆
#1 🥇 Honeycomb Bakery – Nottingham
Common Ranking: 5.0 stars. Opinions: 31
In keeping with Google critiques, the primary dessert store in Syracuse is Honeycomb Bakery! Nestled within the plaza by Nottingham Street and Tecumseh Street, Honeycomb Bakery gives all types of sweets and treats. Right here’s what a few of the 5-star critiques needed to say:
I run with a gaggle that leaves from this car parking zone on Sunday mornings, and after I used to be actually craving one thing candy, so I popped in right here and acquired half a dozen donuts, and they’re good! The consistency is between dense and lightweight, and the flavors are all good, I particularly suggest the candy potato donut, it sounds odd, however it’s scrumptious! I additionally just like the darkish chocolate and banana donut as a result of the chocolate chips are so thick.
Attilio Lospinoso, Google critiques
All the pieces exceeds expectations!! Muffins, pies, doughnuts are excellent!!
Holly Foti, Google critiques
I’ve tried so many scrumptious pastries right here, I can’t even slender it right down to only one to suggest. Attempt all of them!
(begin with the candy potato donuts)
Stephen Gasparini, Google critiques
You’ll be able to see some pictures of their sweets on Honeycomb Bakery’s Facebook page.
Word:
This checklist doesn’t replicate the views of NewsChannel 9 and is for leisure functions solely. This checklist is just an ordered aggregation of Google Evaluate rankings. When you suppose the order needs to be totally different, check out an area dessert store and depart them a optimistic evaluation!
