Pumpkin pie and pecan pie: Each worthy additions to a Thanksgiving dessert desk. However which one wins the highest spot?
“Nicely, I undoubtedly wish to make a pecan pie,” my sister-in-law declared.
My mother, my sister-in-law, and I had been discussing which desserts to serve after Thanksgiving dinner. My mother and I had been assured in our assumption that pumpkin pie was a given, and so we had been bowled over by sister-in-law’s assertion.
Pecan pie? My mother and I checked out one another. “Certain, I imply, we’re a fairly small group this 12 months; I don’t know if we’ll eat two entire pies, however, okay, we will do this…” I reasoned, extra to persuade myself. Why would we want pecan pie after we would have pumpkin? Why would we serve another pie alongside the shining star of Thanksgiving pies?
We purchased the elements for each pies, although I used to be suspicious of the darkish corn syrup; pumpkin pie used familiar ingredients, and now pecan pie was bringing corn syrup into the equation! Each pies had been baked, and after dinner I had a small slice of every. Nicely, it seems (and it’s in all probability not a shock for most individuals) that pecan pie is unimaginable! It was so good! It had creamy, it had crunchy; it was candy, it was just a little savory. It was so a lot better than I anticipated!
My sister-in-law’s household is from the South, and her household custom was to all the time have pecan pie at Thanksgiving. My custom was to all the time have pumpkin pie. So which pie is the superior Thanksgiving pie?
It’s subjective! We’ll must name this spherical a tie—I shouldn’t let my very own private leanings resolve which pie wins Thanksgiving. There are every kind of traditions on the market, and so I shouldn’t deem my very own to be greatest, solely as a result of it’s acquainted. For instance, my good friend from Mississippi thinks candy potato pie is the Thanksgiving pie. Though that seems like a loopy bunch of nonsense to me, I respect her custom, and actually, I wouldn’t flip down a slice of candy potato pie some other day. In case you are so inclined to incorporate a 3rd pie in your individual private Thanksgiving bake-off, strive our sweet potato pie recipe.
Again to our two contenders: pumpkin and pecan. Even when we low cost the parts of pumpkin pie history which confer with boiling pumpkin in milk, filling pie crust with pumpkin and apple, or utilizing a hollowed out pumpkin as an alternative of a crust, it appears to be like like pumpkin pie in its closer-to-modern kind happened within the 1700s. The history of pecan pie reveals that its existence started later, within the 1800s at earliest. Until we’re taking part in by ‘first is the worst’ guidelines (guidelines by which I refuse to abide!) pumpkin pie wins this spherical.
It’s good to eat healthfully, and it’s essential to pay attention to the dietary worth of the meals you eat. It’s simply…I don’t suppose Thanksgiving is about all that. Perhaps it needs to be—extra energy to you for those who create a wholesome Thanksgiving dinner menu, or for those who train even minimal portion management. If that’s the case, you’re wonderful! However for my ruling of which pie is the dessert-ier possibility, I’m going to must go along with massive, unhealthy pecan pie weighing in at 503 calories and 27 grams of fat per slice. Pumpkin pie is available in at a paltry 316 energy and 14 grams of fats—it’s almost a vegetable! And for those who are going to offer into candy temptation, you would possibly as nicely strive our chocolate pecan pie recipe, which provides irresistible parts of bourbon and chocolate.
In “A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving,” when that blockhead botched his pals’ Thanksgiving dinner (what else is new?), which pie does Peppermint Patty lament lacking? That’s proper, pumpkin pie! That is the quintessential Thanksgiving pie, at the least in accordance with Charlie Brown’s social circle—not a peep about pecan. And so, pumpkin pie wins this one. Strive our perfect pumpkin pie recipe to keep away from a misstep like Charlie Brown’s.
Utilizing these commonplace pie-judging classes, we have now come out with pumpkin pie because the profitable pie of Thanksgiving. No exhausting emotions, although, pecan pie—you’re a stellar, stand-up pie, and anyone can be fortunate to have a slice of you on the conclusion of their Thanksgiving dinner. And (now hear me out) perhaps one of the simplest ways to reconcile this feud can be to marry these two stars, and bake this pecan streusel pumpkin pie recipe to your company. That means everyone wins!
Or, let’s be actual, extra doubtless no person wins, since we will all be fairly cussed about our favourite traditions. So, I take it again: pumpkin pie it shall be.
